Description
Sheenwater is on Grand Island’s west shore, along West River Road and the west branch of the Niagara River, looking across to Canada. Like Edgewater, the name comes from a turn-of-the-century summer resort; the neighborhood that replaced it grew after the 1935 bridges. The west side is the quieter half of the island. Since 2018 the former West River Parkway has been a bike and pedestrian trail along the shoreline, so Sheenwater homes sit between the road and a car-free riverfront path that runs north toward Buckhorn Island State Park and south toward Beaver Island State Park, with sunset views over the river. Homes are in the Grand Island Central School District; the I-190 bridges are a short drive either way.
Sheenwater by the numbers
Sources: New York State assessment roll and Erie County deed records, updated October 28, 2026. Market value is the state's full market value estimate, not an appraisal. Ask an Element Realty agent for a value on a specific home.
Address Map
Longitude : W79° 4' 12''
Latitude : N43° 1' 48''
Sheenwater
Grand Island, New York
379 Tanzer Lane, Middletown, New York 12455
379 Tanzer Lane, Middletown, New York 12455, Middletown, New York 12455
6Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
50Picture(s)
1,776Sqft
Your Private Catskills Estate – 69.61 Acres of Pure Serenity
Escape to your own private Catskills retreat! Perched atop 69.61 acres and tucked away on a private road, this spacious 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath home offers the ultimate blend of privacy, comfort, and outdoor adventure.
$839,000
2518 West Main Street, Cato, New York 13033
2518 West Main Street, Cato, New York 13033, Cato, New York 13033
4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
28Picture(s)
3,366Sqft
For rent, move-in ready 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath unit at 2512 W Main St in the Village of Cato: $2,200/month, heat and water included; tenant pays electricity.** Spacious layout on Main Street in the Cato-Meridian School District, an easy drive to Auburn and Syracuse. Pet friendly.
$2,200
123 Esser Avenue, Buffalo, New York 14207
123 Esser Avenue, Buffalo, New York 14207, Buffalo, New York 14207
2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
27Picture(s)
1,095Sqft
123 Esser Ave, Buffalo, New York, 14207. OPEN HOUSE Thursday, October 29, 2026, 5:00-7:00 pm. Spacious yet easy to manage Craftsman bungalow circa 1925. Younger roof, open porch, treed yard and a big two car garage.
$168,900
34 Lindsay Lane, Hastings, New York 13076
34 Lindsay Lane, Hastings, New York 13076, Hastings, New York 13076
4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
28Picture(s)
1,344Sqft
Looking for country living?? Bring your vision!! First-floor living with room to spread out and potential to make it your own! Set on over an acre of land.
$80,000
736 North Main Street, Arcadia, New York 14513
736 North Main Street, Arcadia, New York 14513, Arcadia, New York 14513
3Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
11Picture(s)
4,905Sqft
According to the Historical Society, this brick home was owned by only 4 families, including the current owner. The abstract goes back to 1899, but the home was built in 1860 by Theodore Hunt, who owned it until he deeded it over to his daughter in 1901. His daughter owned it until August of 1948 when it was sold to the Benzie family, and then it was sold in 1974 to Mr.
$124,900
219 East 5th Street, Oswego, New York 13126
219 East 5th Street, Oswego, New York 13126, Oswego, New York 13126
2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
17Picture(s)
1,122Sqft
A lot of time and effort has gone into bringing this 2-bed/1-bath home into 2026 standards. With a living room located in the front of the house, an office space/ play room off to the side, a dining room set in the middle, and the kitchen positioned in the back of the house, this layout takes advantage of every square foot. There is also a remodeled bathroom and bedroom on the first floor.
$139,900
4125 Connection Drive, Clarence, New York 14221
4125 Connection Drive, Clarence, New York 14221, Clarence, New York 14221
5Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
49Picture(s)
2,408Sqft
RARE OPPORTUNITY IN CLARENCE SCHOOLS - Sprawling Multi-Family or Spacious Single-Family Living
Welcome to 4125 Connection Drive, located in the historic Harris Hill neighborhood and the TOP-RATED Clarence Central School District.
$399,000
57 Bernhardt Dr, Amherst, New York 14226
57 Bernhardt Dr, Amherst, New York 14226, Amherst, New York 14226
3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
47Picture(s)
1,644Sqft
Midcentury modern lovers, this home is for you! Designed by Toronto architect Martin L. Mendelow in the early 1950s, this home has been owned by the same family every since and is now awaiting a new owner to bring it back to its original glory! The original plans are available.
$179,000
0 Lake Shore Drive South, Milford, New York 12116
0 Lake Shore Drive South, Milford, New York 12116, Milford, New York 12116
2Bedroom(s)
12Picture(s)
1,360Sqft
Enjoy the best of lake life without the high price tag of direct waterfront! Goodyear Lake community now has a lot of land with public access right across the road for sale and ready for you to bring your house plans! This almost 2 acre lot is located on Lake Shore Drive South and has a number of sites where you can build your dream home.
$59,000
105 Floverton Street, Rochester, New York 14610
105 Floverton Street, Rochester, New York 14610, Rochester, New York 14610
3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
32Picture(s)
1,482Sqft
Classic colonial charm meets fresh, modern style, in one of Rochester's favorite neighborhoods! Featuring a crisp grey and white palette, and updated finishes throughout, this home is move in ready! Some updates include fresh paint, flooring, replacement windows throughout, granite counter tops, glowing refinished hardwood floors, and new vanities in both bath's.
$199,900
0 Lee Road, Florence, New York 13316
0 Lee Road, Florence, New York 13316, Florence, New York 13316
23Picture(s)
720Sqft
This secluded cabin is just waiting for you to add the finishing touches. Cabin is a 24'x30' shell, with a drilled well & septic, partially finished bathroom and a wood stove for heat, plus some building materials. Located on a private road with 3.9+/- mostly wooded acres, this cabin is an ideal get away! Plus the property line is a creek for added enjoyment.
$45,000
5 Hill Street, Elbridge, New York 13080
5 Hill Street, Elbridge, New York 13080, Elbridge, New York 13080
5Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
37Picture(s)
1,846Sqft
This very nice 5 bedroom, 2 Bath Cape Cod home is located in Jordon Village, with many updates, and a private back yard. In Move -in condition, this home has many freshly painted rooms, and was just professional cleaned. Enjoy the convenience of Newer appliances, newer deck, C-Air and more.
$264,900
346 Woodmill Drive, Greece, New York 14626
346 Woodmill Drive, Greece, New York 14626, Greece, New York 14626
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
49Picture(s)
2,277Sqft
Welcome to 346 Woodmill Drive! Offering over 2,200 square feet of living space on a beautiful .58-acre lot, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home delivers the space, comfort & flexibility you've been looking for! Step inside to a stunning two-story foyer that sets the tone for this spacious home.
$399,900
4300 Henneberry Road, Pompey, New York 13104
4300 Henneberry Road, Pompey, New York 13104, Pompey, New York 13104
5Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
48Picture(s)
6,250Sqft
An extraordinary private estate where architectural grandeur meets resort-style living! Nestled amid approximately 100 wooded acres, this custom-designed Andy Ramsgard residence is approached by a winding, quarter-mile paved drive, offering exceptional privacy and a memorable sense of arrival.
$2,750,000
291 Goodfellow Road, Palermo, New York 13069
291 Goodfellow Road, Palermo, New York 13069, Palermo, New York 13069
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
25Picture(s)
980Sqft
Discover the possibilities with this 3.04-acre property located in a quiet country setting in Palermo, NY. Surrounded by trees for added privacy, this parcel offers plenty of open space and potential building opportunities. A large garage with two garage doors provides ample room for storage, equipment, or recreational vehicles.
$59,900
Cr-10, Schroeppel, New York 13132
Cr-10, Schroeppel, New York 13132, Schroeppel, New York 13132
12Picture(s)
272,250Sqft
Prime Commercial Development Opportunity – 6.25 Acres in Pennellville, NY!
Exceptional opportunity to own 6.25 acres of commercially zoned land strategically located along County Route 10 in Pennellville, NY.
$850,000
9716 Mckinstry Road, Machias, New York 14101
9716 Mckinstry Road, Machias, New York 14101, Machias, New York 14101
2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
44Picture(s)
1,344Sqft
This 1,344 sq ft ranch in the hamlet of Machias sits on a fenced lot just minutes from Lime Lake, and the big-ticket items are already done. It has a metal roof, an updated furnace, a Navien Energy Star tankless water heater for on-demand hot water, and updated electrical with a 150-amp Eaton panel, AFCI/GFCI-protected circuits and a whole-home surge protector.
$95,000
1 Hickory Hill Road D, Amherst, New York 14221
1 Hickory Hill Road D, Amherst, New York 14221, Amherst, New York 14221
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
43Picture(s)
1,314Sqft
WELCOME TO HICKORY HILL ESTATES! This hard-to-find first-floor condo offers a desirable open floor plan and effortless living. The bright white kitchen features granite countertops, a full complement of appliances, abundant storage, and a convenient walk-in pantry. The spacious living room opens through sliding glass doors to a private patio, perfect for relaxing outdoors.
$269,000
Cr-10, Schroeppel, New York 13132
Cr-10, Schroeppel, New York 13132, Schroeppel, New York 13132
8Picture(s)
371,131Sqft
Prime Commercial Development Opportunity – 8.52 Acres in Pennellville, NY!
Exceptional opportunity to own 8.52 acres of commercially zoned land strategically located along County Route 10 in Pennellville, NY.
$625,000
4378 South Onondaga Road Road, Onondaga, New York
4378 South Onondaga Road Road, Onondaga, New York, Onondaga, New York 13120
5Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
43Picture(s)
2,736Sqft
. Three buildings are situated on one parcel, including a two-family home, a one-bedroom single-family home, and a former grocery store. Each building has separate utilities, including water and natural gas service. The two-family home and former store are heated by forced-air systems, while the single-family home features electric heat.
$90,000
1207 South Main Street, Shelby, New York 14103
1207 South Main Street, Shelby, New York 14103, Shelby, New York 14103
2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
1Picture(s)
1,208Sqft
Spacious Ranch Rental with Exceptional Garage & Park-Side Setting! Welcome to this well-maintained ranch offering comfortable single-level living, an abundance of space, and a fantastic location backing directly to Butts Park and Oak Orchard Creek.
$2,000
47 Green Street, Seneca Falls, New York 13148
47 Green Street, Seneca Falls, New York 13148, Seneca Falls, New York 13148
3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
18Picture(s)
1,433Sqft
Enjoy the comfort and convenience of one-floor living in this inviting 3-bedroom, 1-bath home, conveniently located within walking distance of downtown Seneca Falls. Enjoy easy access to local restaurants, shopping, and all the charm the community has to offer.
$199,000
4740 Parker Road 26, Hamburg, New York 14075
4740 Parker Road 26, Hamburg, New York 14075, Hamburg, New York 14075
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
46Picture(s)
1,422Sqft
Peaceful patio home in a private Hamburg Community.
Enjoy morning coffee on picturesque covered front porch, complete with white railing & panoramic views of the Association's large pond with fountain. Step inside to tiled foyer where a pocket door gives access to lst fl laundry, garage & basement.
$429,900
2198 County Route 7, Oswego, New York 13126
2198 County Route 7, Oswego, New York 13126, Oswego, New York 13126
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
49Picture(s)
1,404Sqft
Single-level living, 2.46 acres and a covered rear porch overlooking a spacious fenced backyard make 2198 County Route 7 a home with room to enjoy inside and out. Located in the Town of Oswego within the Oswego City School District, this three-bedroom, two-full-bath ranch offers approximately 1,404 square feet, an attached garage and a separate outbuilding for additional storage or hobbies.
$259,900
