Homes for sale in

Elma, NY

Let's Go On A Journey And Find Your Dream Home

There are hundreds of different ways to search for and sell real estate. It’s overwhelming, and you could miss out on opportunities if you don’t look or list in the right places.

About Elma, NY

The town of Elma is known as the heart of Erie County. With beautiful waterways, and welcoming charm Elma is a wonderful place to call home. Elma was Incorporated in April of 1857, and is home to 11,317 residents. The town encompasses 36 square miles with two major waterways, Buffalo Creek and Cazenovia Creek. Elma is a great place to live and work as it offers many attractive amenities.




Homeowners can enjoy afternoons on the golf course at Elma Meadows Golf Course, or a visit to the Town Museum for a day of educational fun for the entire family. Elma also offers a beautiful Senior Center as well as a local library. In the center of town, locals love to visit the town retail plaza where you can enjoy shopping in the vibrant business district. For the little ones, Elma has a thriving Boys and Girls Club where they can participate in fun activities after school.





Elma Village Green is located next to the Elma Senior Center and offers 20 acres of park space with a safe playground. The park also has a walking track, picnic shelters, and gazebo for locals to use. Buffalo Creek travels around the park, creating a relaxing atmosphere. Each summer the park hosts a summer concert series with lively bands and performances. Creek Road Park is great for outdoor recreation like baseball, football, and soccer. There are also athletic fields around the town open to the public for recreational use.





The Iroquois Central School District services the town of Elma, one of Western New Yorks’s top-rated school systems. This district covers roughly 84 square miles within the Towns of Elma, Marilla, Wales, Aurora, Lancaster and Bennington.  This school district is located fourteen miles southeast of Buffalo in Erie County and serves a population of 22,000 students.

Neighborhoods within Elma, NY

Real Estate in Elma, NY

Sort Option
  • Listing ID
  • Built up Area
  • Price
  • Pictures
  • Add date
  • Featured

Price $549,900

75 Alexander, Orchard Park, New York 14127

Welcome to 75 Alexander Way, nestled in a lovely neighborhood w/in the desirable Hamburg School District. This Pace-built home boasts timeless brick & vinyl exterior, ensuring both durability & curb appeal. As you enter, you'll be greeted by large open foyer that sets the tone for the spaciousness throughout.

Price $589,900

17 Quaker Lake Terrace, Orchard Park, New York 14127

Gorgeous new build ranch, just completed & ready to move in by local boutique builder. Located on a wonderful tree lined street. Kitchen features maple cabinets, quartz counters, ceramic tile backsplash, under cabinet lighting and stainless appliances. Engineered wood flooring in mudroom, kitchen & great room. Step up textured ceilings in primary bedroom & great room.

Price $499,900

220 Independence Drive, Orchard Park, New York 14127

Welcome to 220 Independence Dr, a beautiful brick colonial located in the highly desirable Orchard Park community and within Ellicott Elementary! The charming front porch adds to the home's curb appeal and is an ideal spot for morning coffee or evening relaxation. This property boasts four spacious bedrooms, two full baths, and two convenient half baths.

Price $499,900

6308 West Quaker Street, Orchard Park, New York 14127

6308 West Quaker Road; This unique property is located within walking distance to the Village of Orchard Park restaurants! At almost 3500sqft, you can live in the left side and let your tenants help pay the mortgage, or purchase as an investment with nearly $4,000 a month in rent potential! The right owner’s unit boasts a stunning foyer leading to the parlor with a wood burning fireplace.

Price $989,900

7424 Jewett Holmwood, Orchard Park, New York 14127

Welcome to the Forbes Capretto Birdsong Estates model home! Timeless and classic accurately describes the charm that the Newport exudes. A sense of warmth and elegance is provided as you enter this home. Your attention is grabbed immediately by the view directly from the foyer through the great room.

Price $384,900

7637 Ellicott Road, Orchard Park, New York 14170

Welcome to this RARE 2 unit property located in the Orchard Park school district. The Lower unit has 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath was recently remodeled, with a newer kitchen, granite countertops, newer flooring, new paint, and updated bathroom. It's a great wide open floor plan with great size rooms and 2 car attached garage.

Price $339,000

46 Puritan Place, Orchard Park, New York 14127

Beautiful 3brm, 2.5 bath Ranch located in a great Orchard Park neighborhood. This property features: Large/open eat-in kitchen with sky-lighting and separate dining area with gas fireplace and sliding glass doors that lead to a large wooden deck, with great seating area.

Price $460,000

4478 Freeman Road, Orchard Park, New York 14127

This charmer catches your eye every time you drive by and now it can finally be yours. It has the feel of a cozy cottage, but the size of a large colonial! The natural hardwood floors are stunning throughout and boasting a large dining room with doors to the patio/backyard. The kitchen has been updated with modern tile and fixtures- appliances included.

Price $724,990

5261 Ellicott Road, Orchard Park, New York 14127

WOW! This Beautiful HaRD to FiND 4 bedroom 2.5 Bath almost 2,400sqft Custom To Be Built Home is situated on an Amazing 2.2 Acre wooded lot seconds from the rt 219 Expressway and minutes to the Orchard Park Village and All Conveniences! FIRST FLOOR: Open, spacious and bright floor plan brings together the kitchen with dining area/dinette, Great room and optional Sunroom or bump out.

Price $499,000

86 Old Orchard Lane, Orchard Park, New York 14127

This brick stunner welcomes you and invites you inside to the sweeping staircase where you will be greeted as you enter the majestic foyer. Head to the den with French doors, straight to the kitchen that opens to the great room, or pop over to the living room. The choice is yours but wherever you go you'll be surrounded with natural light and plenty of space to do the things you love.

Price $275,000

VL Webster Road, Orchard Park, New York 14127

Seize this exceptional opportunity to own a .42 acre vacant commercial lot just a few blocks from the iconic Buffalo Bills Stadium! Located on the corner of Webster and Abbot Rd! Ideal for retail, dining, or entertainment ventures, this high-traffic location offers immense potential for business growth and community engagement.

Price $875,000

99 Forest Drive, Orchard Park, New York 14127

Steeped in history and with a curb appeal that is unmatched, 99 Forest is a rare offering located in the heart of the Village of Orchard Park. With Smokes Creek behind you, sprawling lawns and a circular drive, the property offers intimate privacy with plenty of space to stretch out, especially on the expansive raised patio.
88 Results returned.Per Page

More about Orchard Park

How Buying or Selling a Home Benefits Your Community

If you’re thinking of buying or selling a house, it’s important to know it doesn’t just impact you—it helps out the local economy and your community, too. Every year, the National Association of Realtors (NAR) puts out a report that breaks down the financial impact that comes from people buying

Read More »

Now’s a Great Time To Sell Your House

Thinking about selling your house? If you are, you might be weighing factors like today’s mortgage rates and your own changing needs to figure out your next move. Here’s something else to consider. According to the latest Home Purchase Sentiment Index (HPSI) from Fannie Mae, the percent of respondents who

Read More »

The Top 2 Reasons To Consider a Newly Built Home

When you’re planning a move, it’s normal to wonder where you’ll end up and what your future home is going to look like. Maybe you’ve got a specific picture of that house in your mind. But unless you came into this process knowing you want to buy a newly built

Read More »

What Is Going on with Mortgage Rates?

You may have heard mortgage rates are going to stay a bit higher for longer than originally expected. And if you’re wondering why, the answer lies in the latest economic data. Here’s a quick overview of what’s happening with mortgage rates and what experts say is ahead. Economic Factors That

Read More »