Description

Spicer Creek Townhomes is a 54-home townhouse community off Whitehaven Road in the middle of Grand Island, set on about 185 acres of wooded, landscaped grounds with two entrances from Whitehaven. Homes run roughly 1,300 to 1,400-plus square feet. Every owner belongs to the Spicer Creek Association, which owns the common grounds and is run by an elected volunteer board. It is one of the few places on the island to buy without taking on a yard, a few minutes from Grand Island Boulevard shopping, the town hall, the schools and the South Bridge onto the I-190. Spicer Creek runs east from here to the river, where the state’s 34-acre Spicer Creek Wildlife Management Area on East River Road keeps 1,600 feet of shoreline as wetland and woods.

Spicer Creek Townhomes by the numbers

Sources: New York State assessment roll and Erie County deed records, updated October 29, 2026. Market value is the state's full market value estimate, not an appraisal. Ask an Element Realty agent for a value on a specific home.

Address Map

Longitude : W79° 2' 6''

Latitude : N43° 0' 54''

Spicer Creek Townhomes

Grand Island, New York

Sort Option

Listing ID
Built up Area
Price
Pictures
Add date
Featured

Grid

List

Map

6363 Muskrat Bay Road, Cicero, New York 13029, Cicero, New York 13029, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 10 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential Lease,Closed,6363 Muskrat Bay Road, Cicero, New York 13029,0,S1588948

6363 Muskrat Bay Road, Cicero, New York 13029

6363 Muskrat Bay Road, Cicero, New York 13029, Cicero, New York 13029

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

50Picture(s)

2,272Sqft

Stunning Oneida Lake Waterfront Rental – Available NOW! Spacious 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home with over 100 feet of waterfrontage on beautiful Oneida Lake. The first-floor features hardwood floors throughout, with bright, open living spaces including a kitchen, living room, and family room—all showcasing a full wall of windows with panoramic lake views.

$3,900

Carpenter-pringle Road, North Harmony, New York 14, North Harmony, New York 14710, ,Land,Closed,Carpenter-pringle Road, North Harmony, New York 14,0,R1602170

Carpenter-pringle Road, North Harmony, New York 14

Carpenter-pringle Road, North Harmony, New York 14, North Harmony, New York 14710

5Picture(s)

213,444Sqft

Building lot in the Chautauqua School systems. Located just a short drive to I-86 offering easy access to Ohio and Pennsylvania. Centrally located between Chautauqua Institution, Bemus Point and Lakewood. Great location to build your vacation or dream home. Chautauqua Lake access is nearby. Lot is raw land and wooded.

$29,900

13419 Allen Road, Sardinia, New York 14030, Sardinia, New York 14030, 4 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 10 Rooms Rooms,1 BathroomBathrooms,Residential,Closed,13419 Allen Road, Sardinia, New York 14030,0,B1594802

13419 Allen Road, Sardinia, New York 14030

13419 Allen Road, Sardinia, New York 14030, Sardinia, New York 14030

4Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

33Picture(s)

1,784Sqft

NEW PRICE!! Great location! 2 story home with 4 Bedrooms, 1 Bath with 1784 Sq Ft on 1.75 acres, garage and shed, with Arcade electric! Large open field backs up to Manion Park. Corner lot bounded by trees. Slight slope to level. 1 car garage in poor condition. New architectural shingled roof with eaves through. Siding is vinyl with some wood clapboard. Mostly thermal pane windows.

$150,000

107 Comfort Street, Rochester, New York 14620, Rochester, New York 14620, 2 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 6 Rooms Rooms,1 BathroomBathrooms,Residential Lease,Closed,107 Comfort Street, Rochester, New York 14620,0,R1600726

107 Comfort Street, Rochester, New York 14620

107 Comfort Street, Rochester, New York 14620, Rochester, New York 14620

2Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

22Picture(s)

7,200Sqft

Step into the vibrant South Wedge neighborhood! Nestled near Lux Bar, the Beer Park, Rochester oldest cinema, Park Ave, and the new skatepark, this unit is surrounded by year-round multicultural festivities. Immaculate and recently renovated, it's tailored to meet the standards of our discerning tenants. Enjoy the improvements ongoing.

$1,550

212 Austin Lane, Elmira-city, New York 14904, Elmira City, New York 14904, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 6 Rooms Rooms,1 BathroomBathrooms,Residential,Closed,212 Austin Lane, Elmira-city, New York 14904,0,R1593481

212 Austin Lane, Elmira-city, New York 14904

212 Austin Lane, Elmira-city, New York 14904, Elmira City, New York 14904

3Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

43Picture(s)

1,056Sqft

This charming single-family home features 3 bedrooms—one conveniently located on the first floor and two on the upper level. This estate sale property is being sold as-is and offers great potential! Enjoy a spacious backyard, perfect for outdoor activities, along with a detached garage and an additional shed for extra storage.

$54,000

4547 Chestnut Ridge, Amherst, New York 14228, Amherst, New York 14228, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 5 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential Lease,Closed,4547 Chestnut Ridge, Amherst, New York 14228,0,B1601858

4547 Chestnut Ridge, Amherst, New York 14228

4547 Chestnut Ridge, Amherst, New York 14228, Amherst, New York 14228

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

3Picture(s)

1,375Sqft

$1,850

647 West Broad Street, Horseheads, New York 14845, Horseheads, New York 14845, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 5 Rooms Rooms,1 BathroomBathrooms,Residential,Closed,647 West Broad Street, Horseheads, New York 14845,0,S1596224

647 West Broad Street, Horseheads, New York 14845

647 West Broad Street, Horseheads, New York 14845, Horseheads, New York 14845

3Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

17Picture(s)

1,346Sqft

This 1,346 sq ft village home needs new owners to love it and renovate it. Location is its best feature. It's within walking distance to the school and Thorne St Park. Other features include an enclosed front porch, a huge family room with a pellet stove and cathedral ceiling, a kitchen ready to make your own, a first floor office or bedroom and two bedrooms upstairs.

$39,700

5055 Constitution Lane, Salina, New York 13088, Salina, New York 13088, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 8 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential Lease,Closed,5055 Constitution Lane, Salina, New York 13088,0,S1602172

5055 Constitution Lane, Salina, New York 13088

5055 Constitution Lane, Salina, New York 13088, Salina, New York 13088

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

34Picture(s)

1,664Sqft

Welcome to Effortless Living in This Thoughtfully Designed Ranch! If you've been looking for a 3 bed, 2 bath single family rental with space to relax, entertain, and feel completely at home—this Alberici-built ranch delivers. Tucked into a beautifully landscaped setting, the brick paver driveway and patio offer a polished first impression before you even walk through the door.

$3,000

139 Strong Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210, Syracuse, New York 13210, 4 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 9 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential Lease,Closed,139 Strong Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210,0,S1601976

139 Strong Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210

139 Strong Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210, Syracuse, New York 13210

4Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

14Picture(s)

1,533Sqft

University area colonial home available for rent on 7/1/25. Four bedrooms with carpet, 2 updated full bathrooms, large living room with hardwoods, formal dining room, updated kitchen with stainless steel appliances, large front porch, enclosed back porch, detached garage, less than 1/2 mile from SU, hospitals. Utilities not included. First months rent and security deposit required.

$2,400

6447 Holiday Valley Road 306/308-3, Ellicottville, Ellicottville, New York 14731, 1 Bedroom Bedrooms, 4 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,For Sale,6447 Holiday Valley Road 306/308-3, Ellicottville,0,B1430140

6447 Holiday Valley Road 306/308-3, Ellicottville

6447 Holiday Valley Road 306/308-3, Ellicottville, Ellicottville, New York 14731

1Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

12Picture(s)

848Sqft

Third floor one bedroom deluxe Type "F" layout at the premier Tamarack Club. This is a fractional ownership giving you 10-11 weeks per year, or about 1 week per month. Your weeks do rotate so in a five year cycle you end up getting all 52 weeks. Weeks are all pre-assigned. This unit is located on our lobby level giving you easy access from the parking lot to your room.

$69,500

33 Champion Street, Champion, New York 13619, Champion, New York 13619, 4 Bedrooms Bedrooms, ,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,Closed,33 Champion Street, Champion, New York 13619,0,S1602133

33 Champion Street, Champion, New York 13619

33 Champion Street, Champion, New York 13619, Champion, New York 13619

4Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

46Picture(s)

1,856Sqft

Looking for an investment property with a consistent rental history? Maybe live in the downstairs & let the upstairs rent contribute to your payment? This duplex has a 2-bedroom 1 bath apt upstairs & has its own laundry area - complete with separate entrance & driveway. Plus a long-term tenant that pays $850 a month.

$129,900

29 Canton Street 2, Van Buren, New York 13027, Van Buren, New York 13027, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 6 Rooms Rooms,1 BathroomBathrooms,Residential Lease,Closed,29 Canton Street 2, Van Buren, New York 13027,0,S1601560

29 Canton Street 2, Van Buren, New York 13027

29 Canton Street 2, Van Buren, New York 13027, Van Buren, New York 13027

3Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

37Picture(s)

1,330Sqft

Available for immediate occupancy! Rare opportunity to rent this charming, character-loaded 2nd floor unit, with so many updates throughout! New paint, lighting, privacy blinds and brand new in-unit washer dryer! Dedicated parking area for multiple vehicles, plus off-street parking.

$2,250

204 Plymouth Avenue, Salina, New York 13211, Salina, New York 13211, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 5 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,Closed,204 Plymouth Avenue, Salina, New York 13211,0,S1601222

204 Plymouth Avenue, Salina, New York 13211

204 Plymouth Avenue, Salina, New York 13211, Salina, New York 13211

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

30Picture(s)

1,080Sqft

Welcome to 204 Plymouth Ave., a 3-bedroom, 2-bath home that beautifully blends classic charm with modern updates and is truly move-in ready! Step inside through the covered front porch, a practical and welcoming space for coats, shoes, and everyday transitions.

$171,000

18 Lancaster Parkway, Lancaster, New York 14086, Lancaster, New York 14086, ,Commercial Sale,Closed,18 Lancaster Parkway, Lancaster, New York 14086,0,B1601712

18 Lancaster Parkway, Lancaster, New York 14086

18 Lancaster Parkway, Lancaster, New York 14086, Lancaster, New York 14086

42Parking(s)

42Picture(s)

32,500Sqft

Excellent Newer Built 32,500 Square Foot Industrial /Commercial building , Situated on a 2.57 Acre Lot in the Town of Lancaster, available for sale. Building consists of 27,200 Sq feet of Manufacturing Space and 5300 Sq Feet of Office Space with Conference room, so total sq ft is 32,500.

$3,500,000

170 East North Park Lane, Horseheads, New York 149, Horseheads, New York 14903, 3 Rooms Rooms,Commercial Lease,Closed,170 East North Park Lane, Horseheads, New York 149,0,R1599216

170 East North Park Lane, Horseheads, New York 149

170 East North Park Lane, Horseheads, New York 149, Horseheads, New York 14903

3Room(s)

5Parking(s)

1Picture(s)

825Sqft

This modern office space is located behind 170 East 14th Street in Elmira Heights on North Park Lane which runs parallel to 14th Street . The space has approximately 825 square feet and consists of a reception area, 2 private offices and an accessible bathroom plus use of the basement for storage. The rent is $1,000 per month plus electric, gas, pro-rated water and sewer.

$1,000

41 Willow Green Drive, Amherst, New York 14228, Amherst, New York 14228, 4 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 8 Rooms Rooms,1 BathroomBathrooms,Residential,Closed,41 Willow Green Drive, Amherst, New York 14228,0,B1596466

41 Willow Green Drive, Amherst, New York 14228

41 Willow Green Drive, Amherst, New York 14228, Amherst, New York 14228

4Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

24Picture(s)

1,800Sqft

Welcome to 41 Willow Green! Located in Sweet Home Schools, this 4bdrm 1.5 bath home is bursting with amenities! The first floor features a living room open to dining room & kitchen, step down family room and half bath. Large front window allows for sunlight to spill into the home showcasing all the great features! Hickory kitchen complimented by dark granite counters w/ heated ceramic floors.

$399,900

1386 Hathaway Drive, Farmington, New York 14425, Farmington, New York 14425, ,Land,For Sale,1386 Hathaway Drive, Farmington, New York 14425,0,R1474056

1386 Hathaway Drive, Farmington, New York 14425

1386 Hathaway Drive, Farmington, New York 14425, Farmington, New York 14425

18Picture(s)

36,155Sqft

Commercial Lot with Exposure to Heavily Traveled Route 332. Great for Office, Medical, Retail or Service uses. .83 Acres with 195 foot of frontage on Route 332. Great opportunity for your business to build your corporate offices. Many uses allowed with easy, safe access to the site. Access off of Hathaway Drive shared with adjoing existing building. Vacant Lot ready to be built on.

$125,000

105 Fletcher Street, Tonawanda-city, New York 1415, Tonawanda, New York 14150, 4 Bedrooms Bedrooms, ,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,Closed,105 Fletcher Street, Tonawanda-city, New York 1415,0,B1601877

105 Fletcher Street, Tonawanda-city, New York 1415

105 Fletcher Street, Tonawanda-city, New York 1415, Tonawanda, New York 14150

4Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

23Picture(s)

2,816Sqft

Check out this City of Tonawanda two family home. Each unit has a living room, dining room, kitchen, two bedrooms and a bathroom. There is a full basement and a concrete driveway. Less than a mile from Niawanda Park & the Niagara River. Biker or walker? Hop on the Two Mile Creek Greenway Trail with just a few short blocks at the end of Fletcher & Two Mile Creek Rd.

$165,000

1583 W River Road, Grand Island, New York 14072, Grand Island, New York 14072, 2 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 4 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,Closed,1583 W River Road, Grand Island, New York 14072,0,B1601715

1583 W River Road, Grand Island, New York 14072

1583 W River Road, Grand Island, New York 14072, Grand Island, New York 14072

2Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

48Picture(s)

900Sqft

Welcome to your dream ranch home—2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and unbeatable views of the Niagara River right out your front door! The spacious living room features a bay window outfitted with 3M film, allowing natural light to pour in while offering energy efficiency and UV protection.

$339,900

66 Lester Avenue, German Flatts, New York 13357, German Flatts, New York 13357, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 8 Rooms Rooms,1 BathroomBathrooms,Residential Lease,Closed,66 Lester Avenue, German Flatts, New York 13357,0,S1601913

66 Lester Avenue, German Flatts, New York 13357

66 Lester Avenue, German Flatts, New York 13357, German Flatts, New York 13357

3Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

33Picture(s)

1,104Sqft

$1,350

5401 Hill Road, Barre, New York 14411, Barre, New York 14411, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 5 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,Closed,5401 Hill Road, Barre, New York 14411,0,R1599011

5401 Hill Road, Barre, New York 14411

5401 Hill Road, Barre, New York 14411, Barre, New York 14411

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

32Picture(s)

980Sqft

Beautifully Updated Country Home on almost 1 Acre Lot! Welcome to your dream retreat! This amazing home has been completely renovated from top to bottom and offers the perfect blend of modern updates and peaceful country charm. Step inside to a fully open-concept layout that creates an airy, inviting space—ideal for everyday living and entertaining.

$179,900

5156 Carr Road, Willet, New York 13863, Willet, New York 13863, 2 Bedrooms Bedrooms, ,Land,For Sale,5156 Carr Road, Willet, New York 13863,0,R1596978

5156 Carr Road, Willet, New York 13863

5156 Carr Road, Willet, New York 13863, Willet, New York 13863

2Bedroom(s)

26Picture(s)

740,520Sqft

Set back about 600 ft from the road enjoy the peace and quiet of this off grid camp built in 2010 using lumber from the property. Sitting on the porch you can enjoy wild life sightings and the serenity of Landers Creek flowing through. Relax with friends after the hunt in the main living area that includes a built in bar. In addition the downstairs includes two bedrooms.

$184,900

1595 Old Route 17, Rockland, New York 12776, Rockland, New York 12776, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 5 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,Closed,1595 Old Route 17, Rockland, New York 12776,0,R1586465

1595 Old Route 17, Rockland, New York 12776

1595 Old Route 17, Rockland, New York 12776, Rockland, New York 12776

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

44Picture(s)

1,489Sqft

Nestled in the picturesque town of Roscoe, NY, 1595 Old Route 17 is a charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offering a perfect blend of historic character and modern convenience. Built in 1850, this 1,489 sq. ft. residence sits on a serene 2.2-acre lot with river frontage along the renowned Willowemoc Creek, providing stunning water views and excellent fishing opportunities.

$399,000

128 Richardson Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13205, Syracuse, New York 13205, 3 Bedrooms Bedrooms, 10 Rooms Rooms,2 BathroomsBathrooms,Residential,Closed,128 Richardson Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13205,0,S1599711

128 Richardson Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13205

128 Richardson Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13205, Syracuse, New York 13205

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

34Picture(s)

1,826Sqft

MULTIPLE OFFERS RECEIVED. BEST & FINAL TUESDAY 5/6 @ 5PM! Welcome to 128 Richardson Ave, where classic charm meets modern elegance in the heart of Syracuse. From the moment you step onto the covered front porch you'll notice this house has been thoughtfully updated from top to bottom.

$174,900

104430 Results returned.Per Page