Description
West Falls, New York, offers a distinctive blend of rural character, local history, and community spirit. Located in the Town of Aurora in Erie County, this established hamlet appeals to buyers who appreciate a quieter setting with access to the surrounding Western New York region. Its compact center and historic roots give West Falls a sense of place that is increasingly valued in a home search.
From a real estate perspective, West Falls’ appeal extends beyond an individual property. The community-supported West Falls–Colden Library, West Falls Center for the Arts, and local volunteer organizations reflect residents’ investment in the hamlet’s identity. Historic gathering places and natural surroundings contribute to an atmosphere that feels personal and connected.
For buyers considering West Falls, I would emphasize the opportunity to enjoy a country setting while keeping East Aurora’s shops, dining, and services within reach. Whether the priority is outdoor space, an established community, or a slower daily rhythm, West Falls deserves a closer look—a small Western New York hamlet with enduring character and a strong sense of home.
West Falls by the numbers
Sources: New York State assessment roll and Erie County deed records, updated October 28, 2026. Market value is the state's full market value estimate, not an appraisal. Ask an Element Realty agent for a value on a specific home.
Address Map
Longitude : W79° 19' 30''
Latitude : N42° 42' 18''
West Falls
East Aurora, New York
831 West Fayette Street, Syracuse, New York 13204
831 West Fayette Street, Syracuse, New York 13204, Syracuse, New York 13204
50Parking(s)
6Picture(s)
54,802Sqft
The historical Engelberg Huller warehouse is now available for sale. Property can also be available for lease and features heavy 3-phase power, 1 recessed dock, and 2 grade-level doors. Zoned Commercial 1 industrial (022), which allows for almost all uses. The property is situated on approximately 1.
$1,950,000
131 Strong Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210
131 Strong Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210, Syracuse, New York 13210
2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
13Picture(s)
1,724Sqft
Looking for the perfect place to call home? This beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers comfort and convenience, located in the heart of the Westcott area.
$1,400
407 Hinman Avenue, Buffalo, New York 14216
407 Hinman Avenue, Buffalo, New York 14216, Buffalo, New York 14216
4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
38Picture(s)
2,112Sqft
407 Hinman Ave Multi-Family Home. This 2-Unit property is fully occupied. Upper Tenant paying $1200,
month to month. Lower tenant is on a lease through Sept of 2025 paying $1000 a month. Recent updates include a new roof in 2024. At that time the soffits and eaves were also wrapped in aluminum and vented. Almost all windows have been replaced with vinyl replacement windows.
$199,000
217 County Highway 20, Edmeston, New York 13411
217 County Highway 20, Edmeston, New York 13411, Edmeston, New York 13411
6Picture(s)
19,166Sqft
Wonderful lot for sale on State Highway 20 New Berlin postal city. Unadilla Valley Central Schools.
Close by Vehicle to the City of Norwich & Oneonta. Near Ambler State Forest.
$9,900
3225 Gracie Road, Cortlandville, New York 13045
3225 Gracie Road, Cortlandville, New York 13045, Cortlandville, New York 13045
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
21Picture(s)
1,296Sqft
This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom ranch-style home is nestled on 2 acres of beautiful land in the Dryden School District. The home features a spacious enclosed porch, perfect for relaxing or entertaining, and offers a rural setting. Rent includes lawn maintenance, and the tenant will be responsible for utilities and snow removal.
$1,800
3004 Nys Route 417, Allegany, New York 14760
3004 Nys Route 417, Allegany, New York 14760, Allegany, New York 14760
50Parking(s)
38Picture(s)
2,696Sqft
This exceptional commercial property, located in Olean, NY, is now available for sale, offering a prime opportunity for a variety of businesses. Currently being used as an auto dealership, the building totals 2,696 square feet and was constructed in 1997.
$1,399,500
26908 Us Rte 11 Highway, Le Ray, New York 13637
26908 Us Rte 11 Highway, Le Ray, New York 13637, Le Ray, New York 13637
1Picture(s)
9+ acres with over 600' road frontage located on US Rte 11 in the Town of Leray, near Ft Drum's main gate.
$49,900
2926 Main Street, Caledonia, New York 14533
2926 Main Street, Caledonia, New York 14533, Caledonia, New York 14533
20Parking(s)
33Picture(s)
34,321Sqft
Welcome to 2926 Main Street, located just two minutes west of downtown Caledonia. This property offers up to 9,000 SF of contiguous space for a variety of differing uses. The floor plan allows great options for divisibility depending on size needed with multiple entrances. Large common restrooms are located on the west side of the building.
$10
523 Stacia Drive, Southport, New York 14904
523 Stacia Drive, Southport, New York 14904, Southport, New York 14904
3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
25Picture(s)
1,104Sqft
Charming Fully Remodeled 3-Bedroom Ranch – Move-In Ready!!
Welcome to 523 Stacia Drive! This beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom ranch-style home offers modern comfort and timeless charm.
$179,000
4986 Route 219, Great Valley, New York 14741
4986 Route 219, Great Valley, New York 14741, Great Valley, New York 14741
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
40Picture(s)
1,544Sqft
LARGE PRICE REDUCTION, PRICED TO SELL!!! " OPEN TO OFFERS " Well maintained 2 story home with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths and a large backyard .Large driveway with ample parking. Large front entry foyer. Side porch leads to Kitchen. Rear entry opens up to a 20 x 10 rear deck. Private Back yard has a shed, fire pit and fenced on 3 sides. (Fence needs repair).
$99,500
5428 State Route 14 Road, Starkey, New York 14837
5428 State Route 14 Road, Starkey, New York 14837, Starkey, New York 14837
85Parking(s)
46Picture(s)
11,030Sqft
A remarkable Finger Lakes property ready for its next chapter! Set on nearly 22 acres just minutes from Watkins Glen, this versatile commercial property offers the space, setting and infrastructure to inspire a wide range of hospitality and destination concepts.
$1,299,000
683 Pittsford Victor Road, Perinton, New York 1453
683 Pittsford Victor Road, Perinton, New York 1453, Perinton, New York 14534
45Parking(s)
17Picture(s)
2,500Sqft
Welcome to the exclusive former Bushnell's Basin Fire House. This premier 2,684sf 2nd floor office space with direct access from the private entrance & elevator is perfect for a high end medical spa, dental, orthodontic, chiropractic, psychiatric/phycological, dermatological or any professional office use.
$19
9524 Preston Hill Road, Camden, New York 13316
9524 Preston Hill Road, Camden, New York 13316, Camden, New York 13316
4Picture(s)
249,163Sqft
Rare opportunity! This approved 37-unit, 2-story apartment site offering is fully available for investors or developers seeking to build new. Located in a tranquil setting, offering easy access to multiple markets, with Rome, Syracuse, and Utica all easy commutes away. Shovel ready with entitlements and approvals.
$395,000
Dublin Terrace Road, Mansfield, New York 14779
Dublin Terrace Road, Mansfield, New York 14779, Mansfield, New York 14779
4Picture(s)
60,548Sqft
This scenic property is drawing attention from buyers looking to build a year-round investment in the heart of ski country. Located just minutes from two major ski resorts and the always-popular village of Ellicottville, it offers the perfect blend of natural beauty and prime access to four-season fun.
$49,000
210 Oriskany Boulevard, Whitestown, New York 13492
210 Oriskany Boulevard, Whitestown, New York 13492, Whitestown, New York 13492
35Parking(s)
1Picture(s)
12,558Sqft
$1,350
7715 River Road, Lysander, New York 13027
7715 River Road, Lysander, New York 13027, Lysander, New York 13027
19Picture(s)
1,704,270Sqft
ALMOST 40 ACRES AVAILABLE FOR DEVELOPER- 23 BUILDING LOTS IN POMPO WOODS OVER AN ACRE EACH WITH THE TOWN OF LYSANDER, 12 HAVE BEEN APPROVED- PRIME LOCATION- UTILITIES AVAILABLE AT STREET- SEPTIC REQUIRED-ACCESS FROM DOYLE RD OR RIVER RD-AWARD WINNING BALDWINSVILLE SCHOOL DISTRICT- INCLUDING PALMER ELEMENTARY- JUST MINUTES TO THE VILLAGE OF BALDWINSVILLE AND 15 MINUTES TO SYRACUSE.
$800,000
1672 Rush Henrietta Road, Rush, New York 14543
1672 Rush Henrietta Road, Rush, New York 14543, Rush, New York 14543
11Picture(s)
Dreaming of building a new home or completely restoring a house to make it your own? This property in Rush with Henrietta schools is perfect for you! Conveniently located 15 minutes outside downtown Rochester, 10 minutes from Scottsville and less than 10 minutes from Honeoye Falls.
$75,000
0 North Adams, Adams, New York 13605
0 North Adams, Adams, New York 13605, Adams, New York 13605
2Picture(s)
792,792Sqft
Nice level lot with municipal water and sewer. No Village Taxes. Street lights and you are walking distance to the golf course, school and shopping.
$27,000
0 North Adams, Adams, New York 13605
0 North Adams, Adams, New York 13605, Adams, New York 13605
2Picture(s)
792,792Sqft
Nice level lot with municipal water and sewer. No Village Taxes. Street lights and you are walking distance to the golf course, school and shopping.
$27,000
43 Baitz Avenue, Buffalo, New York 14206
43 Baitz Avenue, Buffalo, New York 14206, Buffalo, New York 14206
6Picture(s)
8,276Sqft
For sale or build to suit. Desirable building lot, easy access. Commercial zoning.
$49,900
0 North Adams, Adams, New York 13605
0 North Adams, Adams, New York 13605, Adams, New York 13605
2Picture(s)
792,792Sqft
Nice level lot with municipal water and sewer. No Village Taxes. Street lights and you are walking distance to the golf course, school and shopping.
$31,500
126 Casey Street, Watertown-city, New York 13601
126 Casey Street, Watertown-city, New York 13601, Watertown City, New York 13601
4Picture(s)
10,200Sqft
Very nice city lot, if you are looking for a bigger parcel of land then this is the deal for you. There are two lots for sale next to each other and you can purchase both lots and enjoy more space. Right off Arsenal St in the middle of all the amenities which includes the Mall, quick access to ROUTE 81, close commute to Fort Drum and so much more.
$20,000
568 Meriline Avenue, Watertown-city, New York 1360
568 Meriline Avenue, Watertown-city, New York 1360, Watertown City, New York 13601
3Picture(s)
11,186Sqft
Beautiful city lot that is very private with Kelsey Creek running through the back part of this lot. Very spacious parcel to build your future home on .
$15,000
82 Saranac Street, Rochester, New York 14621
82 Saranac Street, Rochester, New York 14621, Rochester, New York 14621
4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
21Picture(s)
2,106Sqft
Fully tenant occupied up & down duplex featuring 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom units that are currently rented on M2M leases for a total of $1,506/month, GOI: $18,072 annually, tenants responsible for all utilities. Both units are updated and feature a living room/dining room combo, good sized kitchens with shaker cabinets & granite countertops, & spacious bedrooms, hardwood & vinyl flooring.
$84,900
